I dreamt about my mother last night. She died last year, and my mind still refuses to impose order on my jumble of feelings. Sometimes it’s loss; other times liberation. One day it’s regret; another day it’s defiance. I over-think our relationship, or don’t think about it at all.
I had little tolerance for my mother. She wanted to enmesh herself in my life in ways that suffocated me. She would repeatedly pump me for answers to questions she knew I would not answer. She called me incessantly knowing I would not pick up. She rifled through my mail, spilled my secrets, and badmouthed people I loved.
My sister asked me last week: “Would it have made a difference if you knew mom had a mental illness?”
Her question has been haunting me. I long suspected there was something “off” with my mom. She was often manic. She seemed to lack a super-ego to keep her opinions in check. She would swear (like a sailor) up and down that she was telling the truth when I knew she was fibbing.
If I had known that my mother wouldn’t change her ways because she couldn’t change her ways (like expecting a blind person to see), would it have made a difference? If I had known she didn’t have the psychological make-up to act more appropriately, would I have been more compassionate? Would I have laughed rather than screamed at her antics? Would I have visited more?
I don’t know.
I do know that as I got older, I lowered my expectations of my mother bit by bit. I fought less (what was the point) and withdrew more. I rarely visited her apartment even though it was a short drive. If she wanted to see me, she had to make the effort. But her visits always made me edgy and left me sad.
So I protected myself. I parceled out my time with her. I didn’t ban her from my life completely (or the lives of my children) but I kept her at arm’s length. It was never a satisfactory compromise. She continued to want me too much, and I continued to need her too little.
I rarely remember my dreams, but I remember my dream from last night.
In my dream, my mom is living in an institution. The walls are bare and sterile and she is dwarfed in a cavernous room. She is wearing a loose fitting cotton housedress, the kind she used to wear. She looks the same as she did before she got ill and died. I can see her talking to me on the phone.
“Mom, I’m coming over. I’m going to take you out,” I tell her.
“That’s ok. You don’t need to come,” she tells me, not unkindly.
“No, I want to be with you,” I say.
After I hang up, still in my dream, I call my sister: “It’s weird that now that mom is dead, I actually want to spend time with her.” It’s a dream so it is possible to visit a dead mother.
But now she is too busy to spend time with me.
What does this mean?
I don’t know.
Previous: My Two Role Models For A Happy MarriageNext: How To Grow Intimacy Through 10 Ordinary Day-To-Day Practices (Guest post for eHarmony)
Valerie fox
Nov 12, 2015 -
Sue, your story touched me deeply. Poignant but also telling of life’s expectations and the clarity that can come after. When I think of my own mother and my relationship with her I also look at my relationship with my kids and grandkids and how they are all a continuum of love and learning.
Sue Nador
Nov 12, 2015 -
Oh my gosh, you are so right Val. We are just one link in that big chain of life. Writing about my mom has been so therapeutic. “My Talks With The Rabbi” was another post that supports your observation. It is so sweet of you to write, Val. Thank you.
Patti Pokorchak
Nov 12, 2015 -
oh Sue!
This article hit me so close to home. What a complicated relationship mothers and daughters can have, especially when there is also mentai illness.
Yesterday during the 2 minutes of silence, I thought of my mom. She was 13 when war broke out and she lived her whole teenage life in a war. Compare that to how we grew up and how ‘rich’ we were living here safely in Canada. My dad was 15 when the Germans took him to war. It’s so sad.
There are many reasons for our moms being the way they were/are. We do love them – but at a safe distance. And yes, we’ll miss them when they’re gone.
But at least – we didn’t turn out totally like our moms!! Only the good bits of them! Hugs.
Sue Nador
Nov 13, 2015 -
Patti, thank you for your lovely note. And you raise such important issues that would take more than this space to resolve. No doubt my mom’s own war experience shaped her behaviour. She often talked about that. She was a survivor and often had to use her youthful charm to take care of her family in Hungary. It is hard to understand our moms’ experience when our own circumstances are so different. Hugs to you, Patti. And again, thank you for such a thoughtful note.
nancie mcleod
Nov 13, 2015 -
powerful…. and complex
you are brave
Sue Nador
Nov 13, 2015 -
Thank you Nancie. It helps to write about all this. With the passage of time my mom’s rough edges are certainly dulled in my memory. She was incredibly generous, and had the energy of ten people. And when I did need her, she would drop everything. Thank you for your kind words, Nancie!
eden baylee
Nov 13, 2015 -
A wonderful piece Sue, truly thought provoking
Mother-daughter relationships … they are unique, aren’t they? I think that would be the case even without any mental illness issues, although that does complicate things further.
I was never close to my mom until I moved away and learned to appreciate the things she did for me, and who she was. As I got older, I wanted to spend more time with her when she came into the city, but … she was too busy spending it with her sister (who’s her best friend). I remember lamenting to a girlfriend about how my mother didn’t want to spend time with me, and my friend told me to pull my head out of my ass. “Why should your mom want to spend time with you at this stage in her life?” she said. “Your mom wants to have fun!”
My friend was right, of course. It didn’t matter that I was in my forties at the time, my mom was always going to be my mom. We were not of the generation where mothers and daughters were pals. We could shop or share a meal, but have FUN with each other like we were girlfriends? No.
Now that my dad is gone, I don’t begrudge my mom for wanting to enjoy this time in her life. She’s spending her fun times with friends, and why shouldn’t she? She deserves this time to do with it as she wishes. It’s just really nice when she comes around and gives me some of it.
Sue, the simple interpretation of your dream would be that you wished you had spent more time with your mom when she was alive … but … that might not be it at all. Our unconscious has a strange way of sneaking up on us!
Your mom will forever be part of your memories, even though she is no longer of this world. The fact that she enters your dreams shows she is still a vital part of you. I’d like to think she just wants you to remember her and know she’s doing all right.
xox
eden
Sue Nador
Nov 13, 2015 -
Eden, thank you. I think most daughters have a romantic notion of what a mother-daughter relationship should be- and unfortunately the reality is often quite different as you describe. I do wish my mom and I had had a better relationship – but despite our differences, I agree that she remains a vital part of me. Eden, you are so sweet and generous to share so much about your own relationship. Sometimes it’s easier to reflect on our own relationships when others share their own experience. xoxo
Linda Dempster
Nov 16, 2015 -
Sue:
There are no credible rules that say we have to be best friends with any of our family members. Further, repetitive bad behaviour on the part of anyone (mentally ill or otherwise), is nothing less than an abusive storm that can go on forever . . . if we let it. I know this from experience.
An ardent wish by most, is to not be forgotten once we have passed. Your mother came to you in a dream because indeed, you have not forgotten her. There is much clarity in your dream. She has released you from her need and now it’s time for you to release any feelings of guilt for having “parcelled out” your time with her, and to forgive yourself for simply having tried to survive the storm. That’s what it means.
Lastly, please accept my belated condolences. The mother daughter photo is lovely – one that belongs in a picture frame.
Sue Nador
Nov 16, 2015 -
Linda, thank you for your very generous note. There are so many philosophical issues to explore. What is the balance between what we owe our parents and what they owe us. That’s a huge one for me. I think generational differences really played into the dynamics. My mother firmly believed that she didn’t need to change and we should accept her as she was. With my own kids, I feel the burden of responsibility is on me to create the conditions that motivate them to spend time with us. I’m not sure I would have understood the importance of this without my own mother-daughter dynamic. It was a huge gift my mom left me, and I feel so fortunate to have a different kind of relationship with my own sons. Thank you Linda for all the smart insights, and kind comments.
Linda Dempster
Nov 16, 2015 -
. . . and your very response Sue, is what makes you the good and caring person that you are.